$$$$$ A Resort Town Mayor Bets the
Kuwaitis Just Can’t Thank Us Enough
by Dan Rattiner
You really can’t blame a town for trying
to better itself. Many years ago, when “The Hamptons”
became chic, Shinnecock Hills tried to rename itself Hampton Hills.
Nothing came of it. Seventy years ago, the hamlet of Good Ground
petitioned to change its name to Hampton Bays and that succeeded.
(Good Ground is a great name. Too bad.) Around twenty years ago,
the down and out hamlet of Mastic Beach tried to change its name
to Hampton Harbor. But nothing came of that.
Lots of places have tried changing their names to better themselves.
The Bahamas voted to change the name of an island off the coast
of Nassau from Hog Island to Paradise Island. That worked. The town
of Port Juarez in Mexico decided to change its name to Cancun. And
that worked.
Which brings us to an American of Italian decent named Lawrence
G. Chiaravallo. Eight years ago, Mr. Chiaravallo ran for the office
of Mayor of the Town of South Belmar, New Jersey and won. South
Belmar is eight miles south of Belmar and was named at a time when
Belmar was a thriving oceanfront resort. It was a good idea. South
Belmar had cachet. At the time.
By 1990, however, Belmar was broke and with it went South Belmar.
By 1998, when Larry Chiaravallo became Mayor, there was not much
money in the till and few prospects.
So Chiaravallo had an idea. He had taken notice of a small lake
at the south end of town called Lake Como, where people went out
in rowboats to catch bluebill, yellow perch and crappies. No one
knew how it had gotten its name, but Chiaravallo decided to petition
to change the name of the town to Lake Como. They had a lake. There
was a very famous Lake Como, the height of chic and fashion, in
northern Italy, about an hour’s ride from Milan. Lake Como,
New Jersey had a certain ring to it. It would be good for business,
he said at a village meeting and everybody agreed and so the name
change passed. At Chiaravallo’s invitation, officials from
Lake Como, Italy came to New Jersey to attend the name change celebration.
And in return, Chiaravallo went to the village of Lecco, on Lake
Como, Italy, where he gave an address to the municipal council,
after much preparation, entirely in Italian. He got a standing ovation.
Lake Como, New Jersey was taking its place in the firmament again.
Four years passed and Chiaravallo was re-elected as Mayor of South,
er, Lake Como again. But the name change had not done the trick.
The Village treasury didn’t have two nickels to rub together.
What Mayor Chiaravallo did about this to try to solve the problem
only came to light a few weeks ago, after he was defeated at the
polls running for a third term by a challenger named Michael Ryan.
It wasn’t anything that Chiaravallo did wrong or felt bad
about. It was just that the town felt that it was time for a change
and at age 81, Chiaravallo kind of agreed with them. He ran a half-hearted
campaign. And he came in second.
In going through Chiaravallo’s desk during the changeover,
however, Mayor Ryan came across quite a bit of paperwork involving
FEMA, Oprah, Bill Gates and the Kingdom of Kuwait. The new mayor
felt a little funny about it and took it to the town council. Chiaravallo
had done this without telling anybody. “When you do something
like this using official village stationery,” Mayor-elect
Ryan said, “the public has a right to know about. And they
didn’t. So we’re just going to leave it be.”
Mayor Chiaravallo, as he had begun his second term, had come to
the conclusion that he ought to try something else. They were still
broke. He had made applications and sent letters to all the appropriate
funding agencies for villages — the County, the State, the
Feds — and nothing had come of it. They desperately needed
a new courthouse, a new police station, fire house, fire truck and
judge’s chambers. Who else could he ask?
And so there came into the picture Oprah, FEMA, Bill Gates and Kuwait.
Chiarivello sent letters to them all, asking for $15 million, which
he said he would use to build new municipal buildings. Oprah, he
felt, might send it because she had a good heart. FEMA might send
it because they were so screwed up, they wouldn’t even know
they sent it. Bill Gates might send it because he was so unbelievably
rich he could afford to send it. And the Kingdom of Kuwait —
well, they were rich — and hadn’t America helped them
out with hundreds of millions of dollars about fifteen years ago
to throw Saddam Hussein’s Army out of Kuwait? The residents
of Lake Como, er, South Belmar, at the time, were American taxpayers.
They had paid some of their taxes to help the Kuwaities. Kuwait
owed us. Maybe just a little.
Mayor Chiaravello didn’t hear back from Bill Gates, Oprah
or FEMA — they probably lost his letter at FEMA, he reasoned
— but on official Kingdom of Kuwait stationery, he got a very
enthusiastic reply saying that they might very well be interested,
and he should contact their envoy in Washington.
Well, Mayor Chairvello, who, before he had retired to become mayor
of South Belmar, had owned a restaurant in that community, might
not have taken it a step further than that, but at this point the
Mayor considered himself a debonair man of the world and a successful
diplomat, having just a few years earlier charmed the officials
from Italy.
Armed with the letter, he contacted the Kuwaiti ambassador in Washington,
Salem al-Sabah, and arranged a meeting with him. This was to be
the first of numerous meetings, most of which were held either in
Washington or New York, where Chiaravello met with the al-Sabah,
several other officials, and at one of the meetings, gave each of
them a Lake Como sweatshirt.
“We talked about our kids and our families. They talked about
— if they contributed the money for the new town hall —
how they wanted a nice plaque on the outside of the building thanking
them for their contribution. I said sure.
“Another time, after the Katrina disaster in New Orleans,
they asked if I could help get the word out that they had contributed
$500 million for the relief effort. I said I would do everything
I could do.”
When Mayor Ryan approached Chiaravello about all this during the
changeover, he was told that just two weeks earlier, he had gotten
a call from his friend the U. N. Ambassador, saying that the matter
was still being considered at the palace back in Kuwait. They’d
let him know.
Mayor Ryan, thus may soon have to decide what to do with tens of
millions of dollars that come thundering in from a bank in Kuwait.
He is also considering a letter, replying to a letter he had sent
earlier, which came from the state department.
“We are unaware of any federal law or policy that would preclude
the kind of discussions that Mayor Chiaravello carried on with the
government of Kuwait,” a state department spokesperson wrote.